Skip to main content
PolisMomentPolisMoment

Situation: new car

8 min read

New car insurance in the Netherlands: how to avoid overpaying

A new car feels like a clean start, but the insurance is often chosen too quickly. The lowest monthly premium can be too thin, while an expensive All-Risk policy may not remain necessary forever. Smart car insurance starts with the financial risk you can carry yourself, then compares the premium.

People in the Netherlands who are insuring a new or recently purchased private car. · Updated: 2026-06-13 · Verified by Pieter Smit (Certified Insurance Advisor Wft)

Start with coverage, not the lowest premium

For a car in the Netherlands, WA third-party liability is mandatory. WA covers damage you cause to others, but not your own car. WA+ usually adds fire, theft, storm, glass breakage and animal collision. All-Risk also covers damage to your own car caused by your own fault, such as a collision or parking accident.

For a new or expensive car, All-Risk is often logical, especially if the car is financed or leased. For an older car, WA+ or only WA can be smarter. The question is not which policy looks cheapest, but which damage you can realistically pay yourself.

Check new-for-old cover, purchase value and deductible

The new-for-old clause determines how much you receive if a new car is written off or stolen. Some insurers offer 1 year, others longer or only under conditions. For a young used car, purchase-value cover can be more important.

  • Check how long new-for-old or purchase-value cover applies.
  • Verify whether accessories, charging cables, winter tyres and tow bars are covered.
  • Compare the standard deductible with the discount for a higher deductible.
  • Look at mandatory repair shops and how they affect your deductible.

Lower the premium without hollowing out cover

Save onCan be smart whenDo not do it when
DeductibleYou can pay the higher amount immediately and rarely claim small damage.Your cash buffer is low or you depend on the car daily and damage would hurt quickly.
Downgrading All-RiskThe market value has fallen and WA+ still covers the main risks you care about.The car is new, financed, leased or hard for you to replace.
Mileage bandYou genuinely drive less than stated and can update the estimate honestly.You actually drive more; an incorrect mileage estimate can create claim friction.
Package discountThe individual terms for car, contents and liability cover remain strong.You bundle only for the discount and accept weaker cover as a result.
1

Use claim-free years correctly

Check that your claim-free years are registered correctly and whether a second-car arrangement is possible.

2

Use realistic mileage

If you drive less than average, a lower mileage band can reduce the premium.

3

Choose deductible deliberately

A higher deductible often lowers premium, but only makes sense if you can pay that amount immediately.

4

Bundle only when the conditions work

Package discounts help only if car, contents, liability, travel and legal expenses cover still have strong conditions.

Compare price and policy conditions together

A commission-free comparison keeps the focus on both premium and coverage. You need to know which insurer fits your car, postcode, claim-free years, household and preferred cover. Sometimes the cheapest option is fine; sometimes a few euros more per month is sensible because theft, glass or total-loss conditions are better.

Frequently asked questions

Is All-Risk always needed for a new car?

Often in the first years, especially with a high market value, lease or finance. It is still a calculation: compare the extra premium with the car value and your own cash buffer.

How can I make car insurance cheaper?

Check claim-free years, mileage band, deductible, security and package discounts. Do not remove important cover just to save a few euros.

When should I move from All-Risk to WA+?

Usually once the market value has fallen enough that the extra All-Risk premium no longer matches the maximum payout. The right moment differs per car and driver.

Will my details be sent to multiple companies?

No. PolisMoment sends your request to one independent advice firm. Your details are not resold to multiple parties.

Pieter Smit

Wft Gecertificeerd

Pieter Smit is a certified insurance advisor (Wft non-life personal & commercial) with years of experience in the Dutch insurance market. As an independent expert, he verifies that our articles comply with current regulations and that the advisory principles are strictly commission-free and focused on the consumer's best interest.

Keep reading

This article is general information about damage insurance and is not personal insurance advice. Always have your own situation reviewed by a qualified expert.